Seeing the Human Face in Supply Chain Data
Moreen Romans has made a career of using data to help companies do the right by the people in their supply chains. Human trafficking is her latest focus.
Is there any topic in business less human-sounding than "big data?" Just about the only person who comes to mind when you hear the phrase is that cheesy, business guy in the stock photo touching the invisible screen with numbers flying off it.
Yet Moreen Romans has made a career out of seeing real human faces in data and analytics. For more than a decade, Romans has been a leader in developing data-inspired supply chain solutions for Dun & Bradstreet. Yes, those solutions help manufacturers with the mechanics of their job: finding and selecting suppliers with track records of reliability and avoiding costly supply chain disruptions. But Romans and her team have also focused their work on the personal aspects of supply chains - how smart supply management can create better circumstances for individuals involved. How companies can do well by doing good.
Romans has led efforts that let minority and woman-owned suppliers more easily be discovered by Dun & Bradstreet customers. They've developed solutions to identify suppliers most committed to environmental stewardship. And now, they've turned to helping companies eliminate human trafficking and forced labour from their supply chains. It's estimated that 21 million people are in modern slavery today - making it a scourge of "epidemic" proportions, to use Romans' word.
That's why Romans and team launched Dun & Bradstreet's new Human Trafficking Risk Index in April.
We sat down with her recently to talk about this latest endeavour - one galvanized by a visit to the White House and one that has her particularly excited about the human aspects of her work.
"How often in a job, particularly in data, do people wonder what kind of impact you can have," Romans says. "Well, here's the impact, and it's a wonderful impact."
Here are edited excerpts of the conversation.
To get a sense of the problem of human trafficking, how many companies have you identified with potential exposure to human trafficking? Even just looking at the regulatory piece of it - laws in the U.S. and U.K. in particular. How many companies are affected by those laws?
We have already identified 17,000 just among the companies on our database alone. There's a lot more, but that's just our first pass at it. And that's not even looking at the smaller companies that don't think they have to worry about it. But with the recent amendment of the Fair Trade Regulations of 1930, there's the restriction that no products now can come into the U.S. if they've been sourced with forced labour. If you have anything at all even in your little local store, you'd better make sure you know where you're getting that from. If you're importing parts or supplies from another country, if you're doing business in the UK, you have to be on top of this. It affects just about everybody.
How many of those companies realise this is a potential problem for them and are looking to solve it?
They're aware of it now, because with these new regulations they have to start reporting on it this year. I compare it to where supplier diversity was in 1998. Regulations passed and companies had to start paying attention to it, and each year since they've had to step up their game. The requirements evolve and expand. I expect this is going to be similar. This is just going to be the first pass. Everybody is going to have to report, try to find their way to the information they need to be able to report, and it will only get more restrictive from here.
Who at a company is most responsible for this? Who "owns" it?
It varies depending on the size and the maturity of the organisation. I was talking to one of our customers the other day, and he handles the reporting to the government for their diversity requirement. I asked him, "What are you doing with the human trafficking reporting?" He goes, "What do you mean?" He said he owned reporting for diversity and conflict minerals, so I said, "Well, a little heads-up, you're about to get this one too." But the responsibility could be under a CSR (corporate social responsibility) program. It could be under a compliance program. Many companies haven't even decided yet. You mention it to them, and they're like, "Oh, yeah. I've got to start thinking about that."
But you've been thinking about it for quite a while?
We started to hear a lot about human trafficking a few years ago. Since then, we've been talking to other companies and NGOs to try to figure out the right way to address it. Then in January of 2015, we were invited to the White House for a forum on how corporations could be proactive in identifying forced labour. President Obama has said it's a legacy issue for him, and we were there with big companies from industries like retail and technology, some key NGOs, and Secretary of State Kerry.
What was that discussion like?
Nobody there was going to say, "This isn't a problem." The problem we talked about is that companies are reactive about it. When they find it, they take steps to fix it. They make the big public statement saying they don't support it. But what if we could be proactive about in identifying the potential for it and then putting a process in place to prevent it? That's where you're going to start eradicating forced labour - when you don't allow it to happen. That's what really came out of it. Just after that meeting, the U.S. government released the FAR regulation [Federal Acquisition Regulation, effective May 2015, which introduced more strict standards and mandated new reporting for U.S. companies]. That was really a catalyst for us to figure out the right solution using our data.
But even so, don't many people think it's still an issue isolated to only certain areas?
Yes, but it's a global epidemic. There are certain parts of the world and certain industries that have more potential exposure to it, but if anyone thinks that countries like the U.S, UK and other areas in Europe, don’t have their own issues with it, they're mistaken, because they do.
It's actually happening in countries like the U.S. - not just developing regions like Southeast Asia?
It's happened in the U.S. A lot of it is in fishing and agriculture industries. We need to focus on the fact that it is truly global. That's been one of the main motivators of the new index.
With the index, how have you been able to accomplish that global view?
It's a combination of three data sources. We look at data from the U.S. Department of State that creates a tiered analysis of risky geographic regions. They assign watch points based on where there's evidence of forced labour. Then we also have data from the International Labor Affairs Bureau that categorises product and commodity types for likelihood to be produced by forced labour. We create the index by marrying them to the Dun & Bradstreet database, where we have firmographics on more than 250 million companies around the world. By looking at the State Department data, the ILAB data, and the location and very granular industry code information we collect in our database, we can assign a risk rating of between 1 and 7 to a specific location where a company is sourcing a product, where 1 is lowest risk and 7 is highest.
So for example, to test the index we looked at a major consumer products company. We looked at the entire company as a whole, and the total risk index was 1.5. But when we blew out the whole family and looked at each site individually where the company manufactured its products, four of their locations scored much higher on the index. This company has actually had issues with unknowingly using forced labour in their supply chain, and what the index showed was that the areas where that occurred were among these four high-scoring sites on the index. Now that we have the index, companies can see these hot spots and be proactive about investigating them - rather than being reactive after they find out there's a problem.
And when there is a problem, consumers find out about it and react to it. In the information age that we're in, when someone says, "We didn't know," consumers don't believe them, and they go on social media saying so.
Exactly. So companies are trying to identify it. But when they're looking at thousands of companies in their supply chains - their Tier 1 suppliers and the suppliers of those suppliers - how can they really manage that?
They can't go in manually and look at all of those. They need a starting point. They need help knowing who to key in on and then proactively monitor and manage with a process that might include boots on the ground. That's what this does.
Then as we do this, companies start working more closely with those potentially high-risk suppliers. Those suppliers have someone watching them more closely, so they can't even try to use forced labour. And maybe we just stopped a little bit of human trafficking. And how good is that?
Find a Company
Receive one free D&B Business Information Report
- Infographic: How Forced Labour Enters Your Supply Chain… And How to Keep It Out 23-06-2016
- Seeing the Human Face in Supply Chain Data 23-06-2016
- Top five hot takeaways from ACAMS 23-06-2016
- 3 Keys to Becoming an Analytically Driven Organisation 31-05-2016
- Infographic: The 2016 State of Enterprise Analytics 31-05-2016
- Flying High Again - Predict Supply Chain Defects with Analytics 13-05-2016
- The Chief Analytics Officer Takes Centre Stage 13-05-2016
- Will Businesses Like Facebook’s Reaction Buttons? 29-04-2016
- What’s Unseen Goes Unchecked: Exposing Hidden Risk in Your Supply Chain 18-04-2016
- New Global Supply Chain Solution from Dun & Bradstreet Helps Companies Identify Human Trafficking 18-04-2016
- The ‘Panama Papers’ leak: A Wake-up Call for Corporate Transparency 07-04-2016
- Sweetening the anti-bribery and anti-corruption process 07-04-2016
- Low Oil Prices, Part 2: Geopolitical and Socio-political Impacts 21-03-2016
- Low Oil Prices, Part 1: Economic Implications 21-03-2016
- Learning lessons from the VimpelCom and Unitel Foreign Bribery Resolution 14-03-2016
- Dun & Bradstreet Reports Third Quarter 2015 Results 06-11-2015
- Dun & Bradstreet Announces Executive Changes to Accelerate Transformation Strategy 06-11-2015
- Special Briefing Economic Impact of the Iran Nuclear Deal 12-08-2015
- Special Briefing on China's Stock Market Crash 12-08-2015
- Dun & Bradstreet Ushers in a New Era 10-03-2015
- Dun & Bradstreet Acquires NetProspex to Deliver Largest Global Reach and Insight on Companies and Contacts 09-01-2015
- Global Economic Outlook (2014 YEAR-END UPDATE) 25-11-2014
- Welcome to CONNECTORS, a new Dun & Bradstreet blog for CMOs 13-11-2014
- The D&B D-U-N-S® Number 22-09-2014
- Forbes CMO Interview: D&B's Rishi Dave 09-09-2014
- 3 easy ways your credit team can better enable your sales 09-09-2014
- D&B's Global Economic Outlook to 2018 - June 2014 16-07-2014
- Econometrics and the World Cup 13-06-2014
- D&B's CEO Bob Carrigan on CNBC 12-06-2014
- Visual Global Risk Indicator 03-06-2014
- Global Outlook - May 2014 20-05-2014
- Is the Euro-zone Crisis Over? 13-05-2014
- D&B's infographic Top 10 Economic Risks by region 11-05-2014
- CIPS Risk Index (Quartely Report Q1 2014) 07-05-2014
- D&B Acquires Cloud-Based Business Intelligence Company Indicee 29-04-2014
- Potential Implications of Economic Sanctions Against Russia 22-04-2014
- D&B Acquires Fliptop’s Social Data Matching Business Unit 17-04-2014
- D&B downgraded Ukraine’s country risk rating 11-03-2014
- Global Economic Outlook Report to 2018 31-01-2014
- 2013 Benchmark rapport - Strategies for managing risk 04-12-2013
- Service message DBAI 19-11-2013
- D&B's Global Economic Outlook to 2017 22-08-2013
- Get Actionable Insight from Customer Data 30-07-2013
- Update - D&B spam email 26-06-2013
- Dun & Bradstreet Announces New Product to Speed up Onboarding of New Customers and Minimise Compliance Risks 13-06-2013
- Dun & Bradstreet Announces New Service to Unlock Hidden Value from CRM systems 23-05-2013
- D&B Worldwatch 07-12-2012
- D&B Focus: A Return to ‘Normal’ Growth? 28-11-2012
- D&B Country Risk update - November 2012 06-11-2012
- D&B Focus: Eurozone crisis 01-10-2012
- Business Information Changes Fast 21-05-2012
- Global Failures: Fall Year on Year in Q4 27-03-2012
- Global Economic Outlook: Uncertainty Dominates 22-02-2012
- Over 200 million records in the D&B Database 29-09-2011
- Number of insolvencies dropped in 1st quarter 19-07-2011